"Harm" and Mill's Harm Principle | Ethics: Vol 124, No 2

This article addresses the long-standing problem of how to understand Mill's famous harm principle in light of his failure to specify what counts as "harm" in On Liberty. I argue that standard accounts restricting "harm" to only certain negative consequences fail to do justice to the text, and that this fact forces us to rethink Mill's defense of individual liberty.

John Stuart Mill's Political Philosophy - web.nmsu.edu

Mill's "one, very simple principle" tells us that the harm principle is correct, but the paternalism and legal moralism principles are incorrect and should be rejected. -- There are two different ways of interpreting the harm principle. According to one, my act must be the cause of harm to others before the state may restrict it. According to

Stephen's Critique of Mill's Idea of Liberty - Online ...

Stephen's litany of criticism of Mill's The Subjection of Women and Utilitarianism is briefer but no less severe: The former work misleads us as to the proper relationship between men and women and fosters a view of democracy that violates high culture and liberty; the latter work suggests the possibility of a brotherhood of mankind that is ...

John Stuart Mill's Explanation of the Harm Principle ...

John Stuart Mill's explanation of the harm principle is not as useful as once believed. Although the harm principle does in fact have some logic, it fails to set clear and concise borders regarding what denotes allowable hate speech. The harm principle essentially states that all speech, including ...

Mill, John Stuart | Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Writing of John Stuart Mill a few days after Mill's death, Henry Sidgwick claimed, "I should say that from about 1860-65 or thereabouts he ruled England in the region of thought as very few men ever did: I do not expect to see anything like it again." (Collini 1991, 178).

Mill's 'harm principle' - Amazon Web Services

Mill's 'harm principle' THE PRINCIPLE In On Liberty, Mill argues for 'one very simple principle, as entitled to govern absolutely the dealings of society with the individual in the way of compulsion and control' (68). That principle is that 'The only purpose for which power can be rightfully exercised over

Mills Harm Principle - Law Teacher

Mills Harm Principle. 1663 words (7 pages) Essay in Criminal Law. 02/02/18 Criminal Law Reference this ... Stephen appears to have been disgusted by Mill's having used primarily selfish considerations of self-protection, in the best Hobbesian tradition, to control and regulate morality, rather than higher aims of good behaviour and moral ...

(PDF) Mill's Harm Principle | Nicole Dunn - Academia.edu

Utilitarianism is an aggregative theory; it does not matter who suffers the harm, or how it was caused.14 Mill's response to this critique is to argue that state interference in the private sphere always does more harm than good, and therefore using a utilitarian weigh-up, liberty in the private sphere should never be restricted.15 Mill ...

The Collapse of the Harm Principle - Scholarly Commons

COLLAPSE OF THE HARM PRINCIPLE Similarly, in the pornography debate, Professor Catharine MacKinnon has proposed influential administrative and judicial measures to regulate pornographic material.4 Her enforcement proposals, again, are not based on the immorality of pornogra-phy. Instead, the principal justification is the multiple harms that

Harm principle - Wikipedia

The harm principle holds that the actions of individuals should only be limited to prevent harm to other individuals. John Stuart Mill articulated this principle in On Liberty, where he argued that "The only purpose for which power can be rightfully exercised over any member of a civilized community, against his will, is to prevent harm to others." An equivalent was earlier stated in France's ...

Beyond Libertarianism: Interpretations of Mill's Harm ...

The harm principle, a paramount concept of J.S. Mill's On Liberty, is often considered justificatory of a 'minimal' state. However, Mill's explanation of the harm principle and subs e-quent applications are subject to varied interpretation. Mill defines the harm principle plainly in his introduction to On Liberty:

John Stuart Mill and the Status of Canadian Legislation ...

John Stuart Mill and the Status of Canadian Legislation Concerning Physician-Assisted Suicide Nathaniel Sussman London School of Economics and Political Science ... Critique: a worldwide student journal of politics ... Mill's harm principle corresponds favorably with the current state of

John Stuart Mill and the Right to Die - Big Think

Mar 21, 2012· We've noted previously that John Stuart Mill's Harm Principle seems to be tacitly in place in Western societies, when we allow others to harm themselves through personally chosen activities ...

Mill, John Stuart: Ethics | Internet Encyclopedia of ...

In view of the fact that Mill's value theory constitutes the center of his ethics (Donner 1991, 2009), the problem of determining its precise nature and adequate naming has attracted considerable attention over the last 150 years. 2. Mill's Theory of Value and the Principle of Utility

Freedom of Speech (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy)

This is much more difficult to demonstrate than harm to a person's legal rights. It seems, therefore, that Mill's argument does not allow for state intervention in this case. If we base our defense of speech on Mill's principle we will have very few prohibitions.

Sample Analysis Ethics - csus.edu

Critique. Mill's weakest arguments relate to the distinction between self-regarding and other-regarding conduct and to his applications. As noted above, Mill responds to the objection that a person who does harm to himself thereby harms others by invoking the distinction between actions which violate specific obligations and actions which do not.

John Stuart Mill: the Harm Principle | filmosophy

Mar 08, 2013· Mill's aim The subject of this essay is . . . the nature and limits of the power which can be legitimately exercised by society over the individual . . . (John Stuart Mill, On liberty, 1859) An increase in authority (legitimate use of power) necessarily entails a decrease in individuals' liberty within a…

JOHN STUART MILL'S "HARM PRINCIPLE" AS THE …

the already polarized and disintegrated society. The "Harm Principle" is an outcome and essential part of Mill's theory of liberty as expressed in his famous essay, On Liberty. Thus, our task in this paper consists of a deep analysis of Mill's "Harm principle", as well as the

John Stuart Mill - Philosophy Pages

John Stuart Mill's On Liberty (1859) is the classic statement and defence of the view that governmental encroachment upon the freedom of individuals is almost never warranted. A genuinely civil society, he maintained, must always guarantee the civil liberty of its citizens—their protection against interference by an abusive authority.

J.S. Mill's Boundaries of Freedom of Expression: A Critique

Section 3 analyzes Mill's very limited boundaries to freedom of expression, asserting that the consequentialist reasoning had led Mill to ignore present tangible harm. It is argued that democracy is required to develop protective mechanisms against harm-facilitating speech.

14 Important Criticisms Against John Stuart Mill's ...

14 Important Criticisms Against John Stuart Mill's Utilitarianism. Article shared by. ... Mill's theory being hedonistic, all the arguments against Hedonism apply to it Hedonism becomes partial due to its excessive emphasis only on the sentiment aspect of human life. In the overall or complete satisfaction of the self, the satisfaction of ...

Mill's 'harm principle' - cw.routledge.com

Mill's 'harm principle' THE PRINCIPLE In On Liberty, Mill argues for 'one very simple principle, as entitled to govern absolutely the dealings of society with the individual in the way of compulsion and control' (68). That principle is that 'The only purpose for which power can be rightfully exercised over